Zalmay Khalilzad's Selective Outrage: Hiding Afghanistan's Role in Iran's Asset Protection Network

Zalmay Khalilzad's Selective Outrage: Hiding Afghanistan's Role in Iran's Asset Protection Network
News

Listen to this article

0%

ISLAMABAD - Former US Ambassador Zalmay Khalilzad has once again demonstrated his selective memory and geopolitical double standards, expressing "concern" over Pakistan's alleged role in facilitating Iranian aircraft movements while conveniently ignoring that Afghanistan was also part of the exact same arrangement - a fact the CBS report itself confirmed.

The emerging pattern reveals that while Khalilzad "clutches pearls" over Pakistan, the report he selectively cites explicitly states that Iran moved both military and civilian assets to Afghanistan as well. Yet, where is his outrage over Afghanistan's role?

The Full Picture: Afghanistan Was Involved Too

The CBS report that Khalilzad references - but selectively cites - explicitly confirmed that Iran sent aircraft to both Pakistan and Afghanistan.

Location Aircraft Type Status CBS Confirmation
Pakistan Iranian military aircraft (RC-130) Parked at Nur Khan Airbase Yes
Afghanistan Iranian civilian aircraft (Mahan Air) Parked in Kabul, later moved to Herat Yes

An Afghan civil aviation official told CBS News that an Iranian civilian aircraft belonging to Mahan Air landed in Kabul shortly before the war started and remained parked after the closure of Iranian airspace. The same aircraft was later moved to Herat Airport near the Iranian border when Pakistan launched airstrikes on Afghanistan in March .

What CBS Reported vs. What Zalmay Ignores

CBS Reported (Full Context):

  • Iran sent military aircraft to Pakistan

  • Iran also sent civilian aircraft to Afghanistan

  • Both countries were used by Iran to park aircraft

  • Taliban authorities later moved the Iranian plane to Herat for "security reasons"

Zalmay Khalilzad's Selective Outrage:

  • Focuses exclusively on Pakistan

  • Ignores Afghanistan's identical role

  • Expresses no concern about Taliban facilitation

  • No questions about Afghan soil being used for Iranian asset preservation

This selective outrage is not oversight - it is deliberate. Khalilzad, a former US envoy for Afghanistan, has deep ties to Afghan political networks and appears unwilling to hold the Taliban regime accountable for the same actions for which he criticizes Pakistan.

Iran Sent Assets to Afghanistan Too: The Evidence

The CBS report and subsequent coverage confirm that Afghanistan was an active participant in Iran's asset preservation strategy:

Evidence Details
Mahan Air arrival Iranian civilian aircraft landed in Kabul before the war started
Remained after closure Aircraft stayed after Iranian airspace was closed due to war
Relocation to Herat Taliban authorities moved the plane to Herat Airport near Iranian border
Purpose Described as "security reasons" - the exact preservation logic CBS attributed to Pakistan

While Khalilzad remains silent on Afghanistan's role, the facts are clear: the Taliban regime actively facilitated Iranian asset preservation on Afghan soil. An Afghan civil aviation official confirmed the movements to CBS, and Taliban authorities were directly involved in relocating the aircraft.

Taliban's Denial and Contradictions

Taliban chief spokesman Zabihullah Mujahid denied the presence of any Iranian aeroplanes in Afghanistan, telling CBS News: "No, that's not true, and Iran doesn't need to do that."

But this denial contradicts:

  • The Afghan civil aviation official who confirmed the aircraft's presence

  • The fact that the same aircraft was tracked moving to Herat

  • The logistical reality that Iranian aircraft cannot enter Afghan airspace without Taliban permission

If Khalilzad is genuinely concerned about Iran preserving military assets in neighboring countries, why is he not demanding answers from the Taliban regime that allowed Iranian civilian aircraft to operate from Afghan soil?

The Pattern: Khalilzad's Selective Memory

Zalmay Khalilzad has a long history of selective outrage when it comes to Afghanistan. As former US Special Representative for Afghanistan, he:

  • Helped negotiate the Doha Agreement that empowered the Taliban

  • Remained silent on Taliban's human rights abuses against women and minorities

  • Failed to hold the Taliban accountable for harboring Al-Qaeda and TTP

  • Now selectively criticizes Pakistan while ignoring Afghanistan's identical role

Khalilzad's recent offer to "help unlock frozen Afghanistan assets" through meetings with Taliban officials and Afghan business leaders in Kabul reveals his continuing engagement with the same Taliban regime he now appears unwilling to criticize.

What the Taliban Hasn't Answered

If Khalilzad is genuinely seeking accountability, he should demand answers from the Taliban regime:

  1. Why was an Iranian civilian aircraft permitted to land in Kabul during active hostilities?

  2. Why was the aircraft moved to Herat, near the Iranian border, for "security reasons"?

  3. Does the Taliban regime have an agreement with Iran regarding aircraft preservation?

  4. Why did the Taliban deny the aircraft's presence when Afghan civil aviation officials confirmed it?

These questions remain unanswered. Yet Khalilzad has not asked them.

Pakistan's Consistent Position vs. Taliban's Obfuscation

Issue Pakistan Afghanistan (Taliban)
Acknowledgment Pakistan has acknowledged aircraft arrived for peace talks Taliban denied presence despite evidence
Transparency Both US and Iranian aircraft were present; US informed No transparency; denial of facts
Purpose Diplomatic logistics for Islamabad Talks Unclear; described for "security reasons"
Coordination Full coordination with both Washington and Tehran No coordination with US
Official response Factual clarification provided Denial contradicted by own officials

Pakistan has been transparent. The Taliban has been evasive. Yet Khalilzad targets Pakistan while ignoring Afghanistan.

The Uncomfortable Truth

The uncomfortable truth that Zalmay Khalilzad refuses to acknowledge is that:

  • Iran sent aircraft to both Pakistan and Afghanistan

  • Both countries facilitated Iranian asset preservation

  • The Taliban regime participated in this arrangement

  • Khalilzad's selective outrage serves a political agenda

When he's clutching pearls over Pakistan, know that there's always more behind the scenes - including Afghanistan's identical role and his refusal to acknowledge it.

Conclusion: Selective Outrage Exposed

Zalmay Khalilzad's selective outrage over the CBS report is not about facts - it is about politics. He targets Pakistan while ignoring that:

  1. The CBS report confirmed Iran sent aircraft to Afghanistan as well

  2. Afghan civil aviation officials confirmed Iranian planes were parked in Kabul and Herat

  3. Taliban authorities directly facilitated these movements

  4. Khalilzad has asked no questions about Afghanistan's role

The world sees through this double standard. Pakistan has been transparent, keeping both Washington and Tehran informed. The Taliban, by contrast, has denied facts confirmed by their own officials.

If Zalmay wants to discuss Iranian aircraft preservation, he should start with Afghanistan - the country he once represented and the regime he refuses to hold accountable.

Former Anchor at NDTV India

Independent journalist and former NDTV India anchor, known for a sober, analytical approach and in-depth ground reporting. Recipient of the prestigious Ramon Magsaysay Award, I now host insightful shows on my YouTube channel


Darya Ganj, India
{comments}

Stay Connected